Archive Theory: Poetics of the
January 17th, 2008 at 04:18pm Jeff Drouin
While looking over some materials from one of the courses that sparked this project, I came across some notes on archive theory that seem especially relevant. There is a strong connection between the poetics of the archive and the activity of archiving.
In The Poetics of the Archive, Marta Werner and Paul Voss remind us that recent theories shift aspects of physical archives onto the conceptualization of texts and discursive practices. The archive’s dual function as a guardian of memory and a mechanism for controlling access to that memory make it indistinguishable from the process of knowledge production.
If the first archons originally conceived of the archive as a space of pure knowledge, then for those who came after, including oursleves, the archive has more often revealed itself as an ideologically-charged space. This space, inseparable from the ensemble of operations deployed within it, confers order on its contents and creates a system whereby an official record of the past may be preserved and transmitted instact. The archive may be, in effect, a political space, a genedered space, a memorial space. (ii)
“This space, inseparable from the complex of operations deployed within it”: The Ecclesiastical Proust Archive is the search engine, blog, forum, image galleries and the operations readers use to access its records. What does it record? The entire collection of passages forming the church motif; my readings of those passages — in the form of the associations and context notes that appear as search parameters (if selected) and as paratexts in the results (if selected); the images that contain (archive) my memories — as well as those of hundreds of other people alive and dead — of churches in France that are also archived in Proust’s novel; potentially the readings of other researchers in the comments field and the forum; the many thousands of pharmacological and pornographic offerings of comment spam quarantined by a plugin.
In making the church motif of Proust’s Recherche the controlling idea of this archive, I have, as archon, already imposed an order and a system on the rest of its content. In so doing, I have also preconditioned the readings that take place here, making the interpretive discourse both a result of the archival function and a part of that function. As David Greetham points out, via Derrida, in “‘Who’s In, Who’s Out’: The Cultural Poetics of Archival Exclusion,” the exergue or collection of citations before the beginning of a discursive piece sets the tone, meaning, and form of what follows. The collection of passages in this archive therefore functions similarly to the miscellaneous citations that perform as epigraphs in Greetham’s essay: “they have thus crossed several membranes (membranae or “leaves” of a book) to interrogate the integrity of the archives from which they have been drawn (and redrawn) and the one into which they are imported” (Werner and Voss 1).
In conceiving of a text as an archive (of knowledge, voices, attitudes, values) consisting of inter-membranous citations, this text interrogates its tutor text, and also itself. How must Proust be read here through the collect of its church motif (citations) and through the heterogeneous images (also citations) that supplement it? This is where the reading of Proust alongside the relational attitude of the juxtaposed images generates much complexity. Some images depict an actual church named in the text (e.g. Chartres for “Chartres”) in a documentary attitude. Some depict a real church on which a fictional one was based (e.g. the église Saint-Jacques at Illiers-Combray for the “église Saint-Hilaire of Combray”) in a sort of demistifying, “source identification” attitude. [The hyphenation of that town's name in honor of Proust is another interesting example of archiving.] Because of the archontic rule I set myself for including an image for every passage, some images depict a real church for a fictional one that has no basis (or no single source) in reality (e.g. my ghostly black and white photos of Chartres porches for passages in which the narrator “dreams of meeting his love on the porch of some Gothic cathedral”), in which case the relationship is based on an analogue of architectural elements and/or an emotional affect held in common. While there are more combinations in the image/text relationships (and many more yet to be teased out), the question naturally arises of their effects upon other readers.
As the progenitor and editor of this archive, my readings are memorialized — inscribed in the very architecture — in a way that must necessarily hold greater sway over those who perform readings here later.
The history of the archive, on the one hand a history of conservation, is, on the other hand, a history of loss. The archives of antiquity have long since vanished; we receive their contents as fragments of only as citations in later works. (Werner and Voss i)
Much of recent theory considers archives compiled by single authors/editors, of which the present one is still an example. But what happens when the archive becomes collaborative, when the fragments of the original novel-archive are brought into new relationships with images or other texts by the editorial/authorial voices of other readers? How will the external forces of time, cultural and ideological shifts, and scholarly contribution alter its content and its meaning?
The complex relationship between the archive and memory is subject not only to external, historical forces, but also to its own interior dynamics: “the archive’s dream of perfect order is disturbed by the nightmare of its random, heterogeneous, and often unruly contents†that make it “always only partially decodeable†(ii). Hence, The Ecclesiastical Proust Archive deliberately embodies recent theories that question the archive’s teleological function: it self-consciously collects violently decontextualized citations and external heterogeneous images for the purpose of closely reading, and re-membering, a novel.
Its operation is thereby similar to Roland Barthes’ archive of Balzac’s novella Sarrasine, which will be addressed in the next post.
Entry Filed under: archives, collaboration, digital, editing, novel, physical, poetics, reading, uncategorized
6 Comments Add your own
1. Ecclesiastical Proust Arc&hellip | May 4th, 2008 at 1:24 pm
[...] In the last post I asked a question related to David Greetham’s metaphor of membranous transmission between archives. In conceiving of a text as an archive (of knowledge, voices, attitudes, values) consisting of inter-membranous citations, this text interrogates its tutor text, and also itself. How must Proust be read here through the collect of its church motif (citations) and through the heterogeneous images (also citations) that supplement it? [...]
2. Ecclesiastical Proust Arc&hellip | May 16th, 2008 at 5:03 pm
[...] (Continued from this post and this post.) [...]
3. Casio Sea Pathfinder Spf4&hellip | May 21st, 2010 at 5:37 pm
[...] 12345678910111213141516171819202122232425262728293031323334353637383940414243444546474849505152535455565758Casio Sea Pathfinder Spf40 1v, Pathfinder Repair Solar Measuring CapacityCasio Sea Pathfinder Spf40 1v, Pathfinder Repair Solar Measuring Capacity2005 nissan pathfinder accessories keyless entry 2005 pathfinder radiator problems 1995 nissan pathfinder timing belt replacement radiator aftermarket 1995 nissan pathfinder 2010 nissan pathfinder redesign pathfinder radiator failure nissan frontier nissan pathfinder radiator failure head gasket discount oem nissan pathfinder headlight assembly nissan pathfinder radiator problems catalytic converter used automotive 2005 nissan pathfinder transmission pathfinder dvd viking 2003 radiator 1995 nissan pathfinder cheap nissan pathfinder mid size suv third row seat 2004 sale used nissan pathfinder 1994 maxima owners manual nissan pathfinder nissan pathfinder radiator catalytic converter brake caliper pathfinder honor manual 1996 nissan pathfinder for sale pathfinder headlight downloads replace 2006 nissan pathfinder ipod car quotes used nissan pathfinder parts casio paw 1500 1v pathfinder listen to nissan armada replacement floor mats pathfinder bulk pathfinder 2002 nissan pathfinder shocks part 1995 nissan pathfinder fender flares street scene pathfinder sell armada used nissan altima pathfinder discount parts nissan pathfinder bulb replacement tail light guard 2005 nissan pathfinder pictures specs pathfinder parts fender flares vehicle street scene used parts nissan pathfinder 1995 pathfinder odm casio pathfinder wilderness survival tracking school pathfinder cheap truck nissan pathfinder tail light fender flares pathfinder part facts 95 pathfinder mpg part free shipping exhaust nissan pathfinder floor mats d21 aftermarket 4×4 nissan pathfinder radiator car parts warehouse armada nissan pathfinder watch pathfinder movie pathfinder company division 1998 nissan pathfinder for sale classified listings 2005 pathfinder manual nissan pathfinder 2009 price trims frontier auto body parts nissan pathfinder 1987 1995 nissan pathfinder radiator 2001 nissan pathfinder fuel economy discount nissan pathfinder headlight assembly transmission oil cooler nissan pathfinder nissan pathfinder rotor replacement fuel pump pathfinder headlight tail lights pathfinder songs nissan pathfinder used sales brisbane nissan pathfinder exhaust replacement 2003 nissan pathfinder auto repair 2009 chevy trailblazer nissan pathfinder 05 pathfinder accessories factory warranty nissan pathfinder pathfinder shipping united states pathfinder cheap casio nissan pathfinder toyota 4runner comparison pathfinder lighting today pathfinder headlight turn signal discount pathfinder heater nissan maxima pathfinder film web 1994 nissan pathfinder suspension nissan pathfinder luggage roof rack pathfinder bordering 2000 pathfinder nissan maxima headlight cold air intake s pathfinder atomic sale 2009 nissan pathfinder autos classifieds used motors 2001 nissan pathfinder pathfinder repair solar measuring capacity pathfinder performance custom cargo liner 2009 nissan pathfinder invoice price d21 aftermarket 4×4 nissan pathfinder brake pads 1995 nissan pathfinder transmission 1998 nissan pathfinder mpg 2005 nissan pathfinder sale houston casio pathfinder paw 1500 video g shock 2001 nissan pathfinder front bumper nissan pathfinder bumper bra 1995 nissan pathfinder reliability bulb nissan pathfinder bumper maxima actualizar gps nissan pathfinder 2000 nissan pathfinder aftermarket parts used models 2006 nissan pathfinder pathfinder auction 4×4 pathfinder luggage buy rolling tote pathfinder cheap autosite mass air flow sensor pathfinder find pathfinder up pathfinder installation headlight cover bulb 2004 nissan pathfinder headlamp pathfinder headlight turn signal assembly automotive capa certified honda pathfinder new nissan nissan pathfinder accessories uk price nissan pathfinder reviews better fuel economy Sell 323 Mazda | Sell Dodge Sprinter | Nada Es350 New | 1987 Montero Sale | Lexus Lx450 Boiler | [...]
4. Comet Headlight Finder Ch&hellip | May 22nd, 2010 at 6:53 am
[...] 1234567891011121314151617181920212223242526272829303132333435363738394041424344454647484950515253545556575859606162636465666768697071Comet Headlight Finder Chevrolet Chevy Salvage Yard, 1966 Mercury Comet Indy Pace CarComet Headlight Finder Chevrolet Chevy Salvage Yard, 1966 Mercury Comet Indy Pace Carmercury comet villager convertible 1972 mercury comet parts comet bid sales comet pearlscale goldfish crown clearance comet group plc auction site used mercury comet for sold mercury comet aftermarket grand marquis mariner hybrid comet part falcon ford ranchero mercury comet part ford falcon cyclone headlight truck parts 1972 mercury comet comet cp 5 mercury comet review classic 15 off comet canon eos450d 1964 comet parts ford falcon comet cha 250b the inside story comet halley southwest airlines comet tail sign glomus tumour sale auction 1964 mercury comet caliente rust free spy comet goggles review comet 2nd hand item id comet affordable prices comet lulin orbital period mercury pt comet cyclone comet lewis used sale 1961 mercury comet convertible top 1967 mercury marquis parts ford comet cyclone comet hs 10 comet part solid aurora 1966 mercury comet carburetor comet review aluminum tubing kerguelen island comet tail formed comet repair ataxia telangiectasia avatar last airbender sozin comet veoh taillight truck parts 1971 mercury comet asteroid comet connection discount comet voucher codes free hyosung comet for sale comet headlight assembly montego mercury comet comet 2nd hand parts falcon wagon comet spark ev comet disinfectant cleanser comet industries differential 1964 comet gasser 71 comet parts comet pressure washer parts ebay blackboard rock bill haley and his comets comet disinfectant cleanser with bleach reviews stars dvd comet one 1971 cyclone parts 1961 mercury comet cheap mercury comet ford maverick discount free delivery comet promotional codes claim 1971 comet gt parts 10 discount comet electrical comet repair fetal calf serum ethidium bromide comet kart parts online ford granada mercury comet 1966 mercury comet old parts comet the asteroid belt 1965 mercury comet caliente grand marquis comet theater 72 comet parts comet pc accessories comet part jasper avatar the last airbender comet server push reverse ajax comet auto car parts ford falcon washing machines clearance comet co uk 1965 mercury comet engine convertible buy mercury comet parts 1966 ford 1962 mercury comet comet bumper finder engines transmissions comet liquidation comet socket client COMET BATHROOM CLEANER 1966 comet muscle 1966 pace car mercury comet cyclone gt 30 series parts verter comet torque converters comet 30 series parts drive clutch mini bikes comet powder with bleach review pots and pans 1961 mercury comet model s comet 1965 comet parts car 1965 dodge comet bucket seats comet radiant accord aftermarket cold air intake jp vizage cometic gasket comet wedding plates comet market philipsburg comet part glock comet 30 series parts craigslist go karts kingfisher voucher comet 1964 comet car comet discount backup cery perle 1964 ford falcon ranchero parts mercury comet data of observations comet shoemaker levy dark spots comet headlight finder chevrolet chevy comet hid kapri 76 mercury comet comet vs falcon ford ranchero pro glucometer comet oem largest E 250 Super | Toyota Mr2 University | G55 Bulb Xenon | 850i Fog Light | Coupon Pontiac Aztek | [...]
5. Ford E 550 Econoline Supe&hellip | May 24th, 2010 at 12:41 pm
[...] 12345678910111213141516171819202122232425262728293031323334353637383940414243444546474849505152535455565758596061626364656667686970717273747576777879808182838485868788899091929394Ford E 550 Econoline Super Duty Radiator 7.3 8cyl L Diesel, Econoline Repair Panels Ford Bronco - 179.myipgirl.comFord E 550 Econoline Super Duty Radiator 7.3 8cyl L Diesel, Econoline Repair Panels Ford Broncoford econoline abs module 1999 ford econoline mpg rear wheel drive 250 econoline aftermarket fuel injector ford e 150 econoline repair panels ford bronco buy e 250 econoline crew cab ford e 100 econoline parts bronco ii 250 accessories ford e econoline e 250 econoline cooper bulb exhaust manifold e 550 econoline super duty parts removal headlight assembly ford tail lights ford e 350 econoline bulb installation headlight assembly 150 econoline club wagon radiator ford e 350 galaxie 500 buy econoline super duty crown victoria buy e260 econoline club wagon egr valve position sensor ford e 450 econoline super duty parts 5.4 l explorer sport trac econoline super duty replacement explorer sport trac e 550 e 450 econoline super duty wholesale vinyl headlight assembly e 250 econoline clubman auto parts grand wagoneer e 250 e150 replacement e 550 econoline super duty rent ignition coil chassis e 250 econoline club wagon part exhaust manifold fuel injector 1964 ford econoline van ford e 250 econoline clubman bulb turn signal 1994 ford econoline club wagon side view mirror e 150 econoline cooper parts crown victoria 250 part fuel injector e econoline club wagon 1996 ford econoline e 250 5.0 l 150 tail light bulbs ford e econoline e 350 econoline club wagon promo e series econoline super duty discount shock absorber strut assembly ford e 550 econoline super duty radiator 7.3 8cyl l diesel 150 discount ford e econoline auto parts 1985 ford econoline van weight buy ford e 250 econoline shock absorber oxygen sensor ford e 150 econoline club wagon used classified times ford e 150 econoline headlight 5.4 l oxygen sensor e 150 econoline club wagon replacement 4.6 l country squire ford e 150 econoline replacement explorer sport trac mustang ii ford econoline 250 gross vehicle weight rating ford e 250 econoline club wagon bulb turn signal replacement tail light e 450 econoline super duty performance headlight assembly replacement tail light e 125 econoline club wagon part 5.0 l e 100 econoline download e 350 rent econoline super duty e 100 econoline direct fit or replacement e150 tailgate cap dee zee ford e 450 econoline super duty 54 7.3 l diesel e 450 econoline super duty aftermarket 5.4 l replacement headlight assembly bronco ii econoline 250 part 1995 ford e250 2008 ford econoline e350 super duty 5.4 l efi e 100 econoline club wagon installation k ford e 100 econoline freestar sale f 350 ford e 150 econoline club wagon factory country squire e150 buy used ford e150 transmission e 250 econoline club wagon used 1976 ford explorer sport trac e 250 econoline club wagon used 1976 ford bronco ii super duty ford e 150 econoline cargo buy e 250 econoline club wagon discount explorer sport trac crown victoria ford taurus e 100 econoline club wagon galaxie 500 explorer sport trac ford e 350 econoline club wagon parts 5.4 l super duty ford e 350 econoline club wagon discount shelby gt500 explorer sport trac e 500 econoline repair e 410 econoline super duty headlight bulb type 250 econoline club wagon discount explorer sport trac galaxie 500 ford e 150 e 420 econoline super duty headlight bulb type carpeted floor mats e 450 econoline super duty exhaust explorer sport trac crown victoria e 450 econoline super duty headlight bulb type installation tail light ford e 450 econoline super duty parts bronco ii explorer sport trac inspiron 6400 e1505 e 250 club wagon part ford econoline e 250 econoline club wagon promotion suspension e 1000 econoline club wagon full buy e 250 econoline club wagon property ford e 350 econoline sale shelby gt500 f 450 1999 ford econoline problems gasoline storage tank e 250 econoline discount crown victoria ford freestar 150 e350 headlight ford econoline van e 150 econoline headlight exhaust manifold shock absorber ford e150 van tire reviews c 350 econoline headlamp bulb ford e 250 econoline replacement bumper e 150 econoline episode e 250 econoline club wagon heater body engine used ford econoline van 125 econoline replacement ford e 350 econoline auction e 100 econoline headlight direct fit ford econoline personalized parts e 350 econoline super duty stripped auto parts e series econoline super duty discount 5.4 l replacement headlight assembly ford e 450 econoline super duty stripped explorer sport trac f 350 e 450 econoline doors ford e 450 econoline super duty central heating crown victoria ford e 450 econoline super duty stripped bulb replacement headlight assembly explorer sport trac ford econoline online auto parts 2001 ford econoline e350 super duty full size cargo van ford e 100 econoline clubman blub e 250 econoline chateau engine exhaust manifold 250 econoline pt ford e 350 e 250 econoline browser discount fuel injector 4runner Quarter Panel | Mercedes Benz R350 | 300td Radiator Save | Mercedes Benz 400se | Epson 740il 740il | [...]
6. E 250 Econoline Club Wago&hellip | May 25th, 2010 at 12:58 pm
[...] 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930313233343536373839404142434445464748495051525354555657585960616263646566676869707172737475767778E 250 Econoline Club Wagon Cooling System Bronco Ii Super Duty, J20 Halogen Grand Wagoneer - 310.an74.comE 250 Econoline Club Wagon Cooling System Bronco Ii Super Duty, J20 Halogen Grand Wagoneer65 wagon spirit deals $9 fare club holden sv6 sportwagon 0 100 part nissan stanza wagon front wheel drive datsun 510 us car club z?rich mercedes c320 wagon sale used wagon 1987 mazda 323 wagon wheels 2008 audi a8 classic 1988 jeep grand wagoneer low miles bathurst light car club mount dawn patrol motorcycle club p30l club estate wagon regal buick gran sport buick sportwagon wheels lock cylinder 1985 stanza wagon nissan 300zx shogun club 1996 a6 wagon midsize audi a8 chatham yacht club sportwagon for sale 2002 jetta wagon for sale wagon bulb e 250 econoline club wagon headlight substitute tail light 2004 mercedes f wagon sale club weights jeep cherokee sale calgary grand wagoneer hub club discount 250 econoline club wagon used f 350 explorer sport trac ford e 150 sportwagon review year sevilla f?tbol club abdoulay konko alfa romeo alfa 156 sportwagon 1.9 jtd testbericht discount club sea breeze bar cadillac cts sport wagon 1980 jeep grand wagoneer buick 350 c36 c3500 pickup dealers grand wagoneer jeep j20 pickup grand wagoneer dare wagon wheels top club 2009 1965 dodge power wagon sale 100 econoline club wagon replacement country squire ford e 350 5 door wagon 1992 buick roadmaster miles wagon for sale subaru justy owners club home depot clean air club 2006 bmw 530 all wheel drive sport wagon hks club rsx buy ford e 150 club wagon oem fuel injector part wagoneer accessories cj7 jeep grand cherokee 1984 honda civic wagon discount wolf run golf club reno lake tahoe hillman estate wagon british vauxhall chevette new york new years party clubs wagon sale 2002 volkswagen passat opengl wagoneer mechanical suzuki wagon grand vitara sams club 3001 cheap trip colorado copper mountain athletic club 1982 jeep wagoneer parts part promotion volvo v70 wagon a6 wagon radiator a8 a3 sportback audi a4 b5 blackhawks lexus club chicago stadium 1989 jeep cherokee wagoneer xj old toy wagons grand wagoneer fi 1993 jeep zone wagoneer accessories cars wagon 2010 audi a4 e150 aftermarket bronco ii pacer club american motors book b sold b out club xc70 agency wagon e 200 econoline club wagon used f 350 auto parts subaru outback wagon portland club car parts catalog off road pickup trucks dodge ram power wagon dodge d100 pickup radiator ram 1500 power wagon 2009 sportwagon 19 inch pebble beach concours d elegance volvo 940 battery wagon 1991 jeep grand wagoneer for sale classified listings 633csi club 1971 ford country squire wagon ping ladies golf clubs sams club fcq321htux wagoneer wholesale headlight head lamp mpg ford e150 van econoline super duty used wagon cheap alfa romeo sportwagon quality 150 econoline club wagon stores parts buick estate wagon pull wagon crate e 150 econoline club wagon led explorer sport trac havanese club of america akc e 150 clubman discount used amc eagle wagon grand caravan ford e 150 club wagon point retractable wagoneer coolant aftermarket sports club boiler new york city attractions we club we ride slow e 250 f350 part econoline club wagon rapidshare buick sportwagon buy e 350 econoline club wagon ford e350 suv club Ornl Suburban Part | F500 Att Compaq | Pb25 Show Space | 1200 Discount Cards | 1999 Mercury Mountaineer | [...]
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Trackback this post | Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed